"David Puente, a former employee of Casaleggio, recounts how, in anticipation of important decisions, the employees and the all-important blog of party co-founder Beppe Grillo would adopt a certain line with the aim of influencing the decision. “It was enough for Grillo to say A, and the members would vote A.”

theguardian.com/world/2019/feb

“It’s a wasted opportunity,” said Yago Bermejo Abati, the project coordinator of Media Lab Prado in Madrid, who was originally involved in designing Podemos’s participation portal. “Given all the initial hope, this is a great disappointment.”

The only disappointing thing here is that there's people out there who believe that adding a layer of "direct democracy" to the system could fix the colossal tower of shit that is representative democracy....

"We may be only just starting to understand how digital democracy can help address the crisis of legitimacy that is affecting different levels of the political process."

No my dude, there is no fixing the "crisis of legitimacy". Representative democracy is a bourgeois scam designed from the ground up to remove power from the people and lock it in a parliament, where it can be safely controlled.

@Antanicus

Well, “power to the people” results in the likes of Mr becoming a minister.

Are you sure you want the polloi in charge of matters?

Especially when they seem to be the first to forget that in our political system, operates within the bounds of , and . Not doing so results in the quickest way to , as we saw in the early 20th century.

Hope this helps.

@61 to believe that the rise of Salvini (and Orban, and Kaczynski, and Trump) is a case of "power to the people" is naive to say the least. The problem is not the poeple, but the 30+ years of neoliberal policies that have devastated the middle class. The fact all the above mentioned wannabe tyrants share the same exact tactics (fearmongering, external enemies, "let's go back to the good times") is a clear sign of this.

@Antanicus
Can you substantiate your assertion that “the middle class has been devastated in the last thirty years”?

Afterwards we could perhaps talk about correlation and causality, but I'd like to see your data first.

@61 I am all for debate, but sealioning is not an option. Consider this my last warning.

@Antanicus
Your link leads to a blank page in . Anyway, I've looked it up.

So we should accept your assertion about the (Western, I presume?) middle class just because you say so?

Being a technical type, I work with data not mere assertions. If you have provided that information on this thread, I haven't seen it.

@61 no, you are not expected to accept anything because a mr. nobody on the internet says so.

But, on the other hand, the evidence of the devastation brought onto western middle class by neoliberal policies is so abundant and widely accepted as conclusive that pretending this is just me "saying so" is borderline trolling. That's all.

@Antanicus

I do not deal with these specific aspects, but I do do market research with some regularity. I don't recall seeing any indications of the Western middle class having become objectively poorer or smaller since the end of the Cold War. The only thing I have seen is increased fiscal pressure (which a priori would be in line with an enrichment of said middle class).

That is why I ask. Perhaps you deal with different datasets than I.

@Antanicus

Btw, what about the *emergence* of a middle class in the developing world and the countries?

Would it be a problem if, hypothetically, some of the wealth in the West had migrated to those places?

@61 the problem is not the middle class emerging in BIRCS countries (and mind you, we refer to it as "middle class" only because it's comprised of people who are marginally better off compared to the BRICS poor) but the way the wealthiest people on the planet (the famed 1%) vacuumed up wealth. See the B point in the attached chart? That's the western middle class.

Follow

@Antanicus
Just saw your graph. Are you saying that the middle class is on the 80th percentile of global income distribution? That's hardly something to whine about is it? Also according to your graph, the highest gains were obtained by those in the 0th‒70th percentile, so the lower middle class and the poor. And nobody has actually lost anything (no negative ordinates).

Sign in to participate in the conversation
En OSM Town | Mapstodon for OpenStreetMap

A Mapstodon instance for the OpenStreetMap Community (English language)! This site is under construction, and may change. Our francophone friends have a Mastodon instance: fr.osm.social